Offline
I'm curious: Is there any media groundswell out there in Eugene and Portland about revisiting football for the fall? With the BIG-10 potentially changing course, I have heard nothing about the PAC-12. Nothing from Scott. Nothing from Wilner. Little from Canzano. Lots of lamentations from Goe.
I'm an Oregon democrat in most things. I am sick that this whole issue is getting politicized. Of course Trump is pandering in the midwest, because Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin are huge states in the upcoming election. I think two things make football possible in the PAC-12 this fall, but it would take the CEO group swallowing their pride and reversing course:
1. These new rapid saliva test kits are cheap (I have heard the figure $5.00!) and agile. We can test and isolate athletes the morning of contests.
2. The opt-out option preserves eligibility and gives the power to the athlete. Ten UCF players, including two starters and a really good backup QB, just opted out! More than fifty top players whose teams are playing in the fall have opted out. The athletes have control, so they can make that choice and come back in the fall.
I would fully expect a number of critically important PAC-12 players to opt out if the season hadn't been canceled. I think all sports should be back on for the fall in the PAC-12, with limited audience access (20%?) and stringent protocols. An SEC coach made the statement that athletes opting out of football are opting into the pandemic. I can't say it's eloquent phrasing, but I see his point: these athletes have better care and oversight than the average college student.
I hope the CEO group at least meets to discuss what might happen if the BIG-10 jumps back in. It's just bad for the conference to be shuttered while these teams are on display in the fall.
Offline
PDX to JAX wrote:
I'm curious: Is there any media groundswell out there in Eugene and Portland about revisiting football for the fall? With the BIG-10 potentially changing course, I have heard nothing about the PAC-12. Nothing from Scott. Nothing from Wilner. Little from Canzano. Lots of lamentations from Goe.
I'm an Oregon democrat in most things. I am sick that this whole issue is getting politicized. Of course Trump is pandering in the midwest, because Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin are huge states in the upcoming election. I think two things make football possible in the PAC-12 this fall, but it would take the CEO group swallowing their pride and reversing course:
1. These new rapid saliva test kits are cheap (I have heard the figure $5.00!) and agile. We can test and isolate athletes the morning of contests.
2. The opt-out option preserves eligibility and gives the power to the athlete. Ten UCF players, including two starters and a really good backup QB, just opted out! More than fifty top players whose teams are playing in the fall have opted out. The athletes have control, so they can make that choice and come back in the fall.
I would fully expect a number of critically important PAC-12 players to opt out if the season hadn't been canceled. I think all sports should be back on for the fall in the PAC-12, with limited audience access (20%?) and stringent protocols. An SEC coach made the statement that athletes opting out of football are opting into the pandemic. I can't say it's eloquent phrasing, but I see his point: these athletes have better care and oversight than the average college student.
I hope the CEO group at least meets to discuss what might happen if the BIG-10 jumps back in. It's just bad for the conference to be shuttered while these teams are on display in the fall.
The only sport I am crazy about is college football, and to not have a season is crushing. However, we are seeing a significant rise in cases as colleges reopen. Many have started, and then shut down. There is nothing more important than the health of the student-athletes. Until there is a safe and reliable vaccine, I just don't see how anybody can play. While I do feel for kids caught up in this lousy situation, I also feel for the over 187,000 people dead, and their families and friends. We shall see, but I can live with no football this year if it means keeping kids safe, even if those kids are willing to play.
Offline
I posted something similar on the last thread... After digesting a reply from ORG...
1) It is doubtful that the season will be fully played out. Combo of opt-outs and mid-season positive tests will upset the balance of power in this sport, and I can just hear St. Nick trying to invalidate and de-legitimize the season if his team falls below .500 for any reason and some teams just might pack it in before Thanksgiving.
2) Yup, politics is in everything. Of course there is a pandering to fans for football, the candidate only speaking the language. The officials say different, why spend millions upon millions if only to have what I describe in #1 happen...?
3) Scott seems to have shut and padlocked the doors of the P12 for Fall. His silence is deafening on the matter anymore, and yes, being the only P5 conference opting out in full resonates on the landscape. Think he is betting that the disaster scenario indeed plays out and seasons are shuttered prematurely. I have plenty of negative to say about this dude, but cannot fault him without hindsight on this one...
4) Oregon football should weather this storm, my sense is that many players would have opted out anyway. As a player, it probably stings to watch the other teams take the field in September, its on the coaches to manage these emotions as best they can and keep looking forward...
Offline
I appreciate the thoughtful responses, ORG and Jiffy Jeff! It's a complex issue, to be sure. Very glad these institutions and the NCAA have done the right thing and allowed these athletes to avoid competition without losing eligibility. I don't think the CEO group will reverse course, and it will make for a strange fall.
But the other side of the coin is intriguing. If the PAC-12 plays in the winter/spring, the exposure would be off the charts. They would be the only game on...
Offline
the Pac-12 and its CEO Group will come out smelling like Roses if some other conferences press ahead and attempt to play this Fall. nothing but disaster down that road, and very little to gain for the risk.
Spring Football, with fans in the stadium, for me is worth the wait.